The Aftermath
Oh, boy. Here we go.
I was 100% sure I'd have to do another entry on the "Without A Trace" episode regarding what I had said about the episode before it aired.
Because sure enough, the posts: (Post 1, Post 2),
And comments:
THANK YOU for playing a TV drama the hot EVERY SINGLE Korean stereotype out there.
SELLOUT
It may not be a typical " Asian theme" storyline, but it's more like
of a "let's go to the Korean corner store and bust up my sister episode."
I know it's about being paid, but you could've stood up on this
I just hope you knows [sic] that you are spouting bullshit, but I have this feeling you may have deluded yourself into believing what was written.
And emails started flowing in:
Subj: Without A Trace -Are you Kidding me?
Hey, Parry, didn't you notice that this EP hit EVERYSINGLE FRICKIN' Asian stereotype? I just watched it and spent the last hour and a half vomiting. Great job, Parry.
And this has been my official response:
Nope--I'm not kidding you.
I still stand by what I said. I audition a lot and my part was some of the better dialogue I've personally read for - Asian part or non. And maybe that's a sad commentary in itself. All I know is what I know.
There are truths to stereotypes, my friend. I still see this kind of old world expectation stuff and expectations put on college students from their parents all the time--as a matter of fact just yesterday when I was at Northeastern University.
So just because you've seen it before, doesn't mean it's not realistic.
And the performances were extremely solid on the show because of the writing and vice versa. Not speaking for myself, cuz that would be presumptuous, but Nicole Bilderback and especially Kelvin Yu (he showed some major acting chops at the end) and proved to the world that Asian-Americans can act (the usual excuse of producers in the business to not cast Asians) -- and that maybe it's about time they be utilized in some other stuff. It's all baby steps, man.
There was nothing to stand up to. You have to work from within the system to change things. And I think we did that--because believe me... it could have been a lot worse in lesser hands (and we couldn't do that if the show was absolute "ass").
I feel this one reader's comment "got it":
I watched last nite and thought that everyone's performance was really strong. I'm not familiar with the show, but thought that Nicole Bilderback's Roshomon like performance was very good, how different she was in each flashback depending on who was telling the story. Although the set up was a little disappointing (Korean grocery store, old world parents, independent gal struggling to break free), I thought the writing and the performances elevated the story above the stereotypical set up. Kudos!
So I'm not saying what all the folks above had to say is without merit -- I'm not oblivious to the setup. But a lot of the comments and reactions to the episode have people looking at things very narrowly.
I'm actually kind of glad all these posts are up because it clearly illustrates exactly what I touch upon in my speaking engagements when I say there's this vat of "haterade" that is often dipped into within the Asian-American community's ranks and as a result, we are so disjointed as a community.
I mean come on, having me get criticized for playing a Korean because I'm really Chinese? (I got the same flack for playing a Filipino in "BLT" as well. Did DeNiro get this much flack for playing 1/2 Irish in "Goodfellas"?) And how about Daniel Dae Kim from "Lost" receiving hate mail from the Korean Community because he doesn't speak fluent Korean -- while the rest of the Asian Community bags on him because he doesn't speak English on the show? Or people who call Justin Lin a sellout for doing "Fast and the Furious 3" and are so horrified having him do the remake of "Oldboy"?
It's about looking at the big picture. Daniel's on a Top 5 rated show - millions of people are seeing a talented Asian Actor kick major butt week after week on screen and is now on the American Public's radar. Justin is now working at the studio level and gaining respect there -- that respect gave him the leverage to offer Roger Fan a very coveted role in "Annapolis" (even though Hollywood had other choices, all non-Asian of course) and then that allowed him to also bring back Sung Kang and Jason Tobin in "FF3".
Yes, I know, it's "FF3" -- but would it be better to have the film filled with the rappers who can't act that the studio originally wanted? Should Justin continue doing only little independent films and gain no clout whatsoever? Regarding "Without A Trace", would it have been better to have even less Asians on screen? Would it be better if Daniel wasn't on "Lost"? (And I guarantee if Daniel Dae Kim's character ever gets killed off in "Lost", the Korean/Asian community would be in an uproar and recanting their previous "Negative-Jin" statements.)
Here's a true story: After "BLT", I turned down everything that came my way. I was the biggest snob. I was going to "stand my ground" and any project that had the slightest hint of being perceived as stereotypical or anything less than the quality of "BLT" -- I turned down.
And you know how many projects I worked on the year after "BLT"?
One.
You know how much money I made from acting in 2002?
$384.62
And that's when I made the decision that I was not doing anybody any good just sitting on the sidelines. I couldn't change anything that way. And it wasn't just about the money - it also crippling me mentally as well as professionally.
So I started 2003 with the understanding that it would be a continuing journey and battle -- not every project was going to be as progressive as "BLT" and I'd have to take every part that I could and make it a fully realized performance -- spin gold out of whatever role I was given no matter the project. Not only continuing to bring in income and working but also doing the best I could representing Asian-Americans on screen to the public. All that negative energy just moping around was so unproductive.
A study from the Screen Actors Guild just came out. In 2004, there were 31,173 total roles in Film/TV.
917 of them went to Asian/Pacific Actors.
Which clearly demonstrates even more so why AA Actors have got make the most of what's there -- which is 2.9% of the theatrical roles. Writing our own roles, etc is obviously the way to go in the long run but as far as what to do in the here and now? In my opinion, the responsibility of the AA actor is to be so good in any role so that audiences, casting directors, producers watching will go "Wow, who was that?" Because once that happens, the "race thing" bleeds away. Or we can continue to have a chip on our shoulders, moan and bitch about every little issue-- giving producers more of an excuse to whittle down those numbers and have our representation totally disappear on screen.
Every role I've taken after "BLT" has been a real effort in terms of changing dialogue and characterizations to minimize a stereotype or incorrect depiction -- that was not the case with my role in "Without A Trace". It was a dream to work on because I did not have to change or asked the dialogue/situations to be altered -- which is why I said it was one of the best experiences I've had filming.
But this is what progress is. It's slow but forward moving. I'm not saying never speak up for certain issues -- but it has to be focused in the proper direction, otherwise it's just a bunch of noise from those "yellow people" again. Racist Ambercrombie & Fitch shirts? Worth speaking up against. Protesting that a housing development isn't being built conducive to Feng-Sui? Not worth speaking up against. Racist Tsunami song on Hot 97? Worth speaking up against. A bunch of Chinese actors not playing their own Asian ethnicity? Not so much.
Micro-bashing everything in sight is one of the major, major reasons why we as a community are so far behind the solidarity of say, the African-American community (ex: The African-American community does not bag on Terrence Howard for playing a pimp all the time.) We partly oppress ourselves and lose our collective strength when we do.
There I said it -- but the truth sometimes hurts. Hate me, un-subscribe from me, set up boycott campaigns for my future projects ... but those with leveler heads will look at the bigger picture and realize that I'm on your side and will seriously delve into how we can solve this "haterade" issue as a unified community.
Let the hate mail and comments begin. (Whew, I'm taking a huge breath as I hit "submit" on this one!)











that's like "Preparation H" going with the name "Ass Cream" or "Sphincter Gel". The real product name: "Vagisil" also makes me shake my head in disbelief.


















Recent Comments