May 17, 2005

  • To Accent, or Not to Accent?


    Man, I am wiped.


    Today was my first day off after shooting six nights in a row.  In sleeping during through the daytimes, I think I’ve lost a little bit of sleep each day.  So during my one day off, I slept in for like, 15 hours – many guests had even visited my house, talked to my wife, played with the baby and left without me being none the wiser.


    I’ve got about 3 more nights of this and then I’ll be wrapped.  The cool part is that I’ve yet to see “Hatchet” in full makeup yet since the writer/director, Adam Green, wants to get a shot of an honest first reaction.


    And speaking about the director, he’s been a very, very cool guy to work with. 


    At first the role called for a Chinese Accent that was kind of integral for my character’s setup.  However, in my auditions, I did a Bostonian Accent in lieu since my character mentions that he’s from Boston.  The director loved the choice but once he booked me for the part, asked if I would change the character back to speaking with a Chinese Accent.


    I talked to him about being uncomfortable doing a Chinese Accent and not wanting to perpetuate such a stereotype after “BLT” and that I would not have accepted the part if I had to do so (since I always maintained the Bostonian Accent throughout all my auditions). 


    The director entirely understood and immediately made arrangements to take out all references of a Chinese Accent entirely. 


    However, without giving away any plotlines, I was able to come up with a solution that was able to incorporate the director’s original vision while still maintaining a progressive Asian-American character onscreen – as well as keeping my self-respect. 


    John Cho did something similar when offered his role in “Big Fat Liar“.  I remember he was troubled on whether or not to take the role because it called for use of a thick Asian Accent.  His solution: To give a different take on the character (sans Accent) that the producers wound up loving.


    I address this during a portion in my speaking engagements:  That the line of stereotypes and racism these days is so subtle and minute.  The obvious situations are hate-crimes and bigotry — but most of the time it’s just plain ‘ole ignorance. 


    If a certain image or archetype is constantly exposed to a mass audience — that’s all they will know.  You can’t really blame them.  And in turn, this exposure also gets into the minds of the future writers and directors of tomorrow.  I’ve lost out on a lot of parts because my initial choice wasn’t to use an Asian Accent for the character.  And no, I wasn’t told or forced to do one by the producers – I just wasn’t hired.  And someone who was willing to make the choice of doing an Asian Accent was.  Hence the vicious cycle. 


    And what I mention in the speaking gigs is to not be militant or soapbox-ish about correcting people but working from within — doing your small part when the situation arises, towards changing the way things have been ingrained in our society for decades. 


    My stunt double on “Hatchet” (who is Asian-American and has seen a lot having been in the business since 1989) was very surprised when I told him about my request to change the character because he’s so used to seeing the path of least resistance taken in such situations.  You usually just wind up just swallowing it and dealing with the lump in your throat later.  But in doing so, ironically makes it that much harder for the same actor in the future. 


    In an alternate universe, if John Cho hadn’t spoken up on “Big Fat Liar“, there forever would’ve been yet another “ching-chong” example of an Asian character for the mass public to reference.  And say, a budding writer would unknowingly create a similar character based on the stereotypical humor because he was a fan of the film.


    But because John spoke up, now that budding writer can’t.  And with the adjustment on “Hatchet“, that budding writer still can’t either.


    However, it’s also a huge testament to the director, Adam Green, that he listened.  Because he could’ve just as easily fired me after my talk with him and hired some other Asian kid to replace me.  Someone that probably would’ve just shut up and taken the money… and the thing is — I wouldn’t even blame the actor for taking the part. 


    Because honestly, how often does anyone (non-actors) ever worry about the betterment of their community whenever they’re hired for a new job?  Therein lies the rub.  The title of this entry should be changed to… To Eat/Pay rent or Not to Eat/Pay Rent?      

Comments (43)

  • That’s awesome. Way to take a stand! It is kind of annoying seeing all of those “ching chong” types on tv and in movies… <3 Nancy

  • eh? That is always seem to be the case with Asian actors. Props to Mr. Green to allow Asian American actors to grow beyond stereotypical stamp of being Asian actors instead of just actors like everyone else. I hope there are more directors like him in the future!

  • Ah, one step at a time, eh?

  • Keep with the struggle, brotha.  Its rare to see people stand up for what they believe anymore.

  • GOOD JOB MAN! ONE SMALL STEP FOR ONE ASIAN MAN, ONE GIANT LEAP FOR ASIAN MANKIND.

  • Great post.  While fighting stereotypes (diplomatically and effectively) is a challenge for all AA’s in our various lines of work, those in media/entertainment have an awesome responsibility due to the high visibility and profile so it’s fantastic for you to speak up about ways to handle the situation and make some progress!

  • fight the power, keep it up

  • fight the good fight

  • yay i’m so glad to hear! props parry! =)

  • i am so glad that there are actors like you that considers the choice of not using a chinese accent.  it is hard enough for any actor that isnt a A lister to have jobs, that saying no, or keeping integrity is a tough choice.  also, i remember lucy liu saying, that shes just an actress and not a symbol of asian actresses, the roles she chooses are because she chose them for whatever reason, not for the grand scheme of asian being in the media. i respect that. but i double thank you for doing what you do.

    i actually just say harold and kumar, and the movie is awesome. because despite all the comedy, the comedy only works because there is the ingrained stereotypes that is true somewhere. 

    have you seen sandra oh in double happiness? theres a scene that is similar this whole situation.

  • We’re doing some post work on Hatchet at my work. I have yet to see any footage, but I’m keeping my eyes open for you.

  • Bravo.  Choices like these often seem to be minute decisions when it comes to getting a job or not, especially when moola is involved.  Choices like these are the types that motion for the changes in representation of Asians in media.  And for that, I will give 2 eprops. yay. 

  • Good shit man, i’m so sick of seeing them try to portray us Asians like jackasses.

  • omgosh, your so awesome :) im so proud you did that lol, even tho i don’t know you. but still! i admire your courage a lot. paz mai

  • i liked this post! i’m glad there are actors/people like you out there. it’s admirable

  • you are appreciated.

  • It’s good to hear that things are slowly but surely changing in Hollyweird.  Rock on for listening to your heart and in doing so maybe putting a paycheck in jeapordy but doing it for the right reason. 

    Living in Boston now, I can’t wait to hear “PAWK YAH CAH”.

  • I see ur working with laods of good celebs like merceds mcnab ive met her shes ok.

  • It’s good to hear that people are standing up for what they believe in, even if it means that that person may loose their job.  I understand you can only speak for Asian American, but I do wish someone in the film industry spoke up for the Hispanics in the world.  Every movie I watch involves Hispanics with little to no education, high school students have kids and living off of welfare in a roach infested New York apartments.  For once it would be nice to see the well educated Hispanic that pays their taxes on their nice house and car that got everything from working hard and not by selling drugs (like the movie industry seems to portray).  Anyway, I’m glad to hear that you are going something to make things right.  It would be nice if there were more people (of all races) out there like you.

  • thank you for standing up for us asians.

  • This above all,–to thine own self be true

    What a great post. It was brave of you to take that risk when it could have been so easy to just let it slide. Thank you. Small actions will add up one by one and we have to believe that it will pay off in the end… that the pendulum will swing the other way (even if we have to drag it there, kicking and screaming) and that there will be a time when this won’t have to be a topic of discussion. Some battles are worth fighting.

    Though this be madness, yet there is method in ‘t.”

    couldn’t resist the keeping up the hamlet theme ;)

  • That’s some great courage! Very admirable.

  • I’m so proud of you and John for not deciding to take on a role which may support such a stereotype.  Indeed, fight the power!

  • kicking ass, one movie at a time. Sleep it up, Parry.

  • way to think things through

  • fabulous. thank God someone is out there breaking the stereotype of what we are like as Chinese( Americans)!

  • way to go to fight against the stereotype! i just wrote a research paper on that topic…asian american stereotypes in the american media…and i actually referenced BLT…so that’s awesome

  • Perry those are some good things you guys are all doing. Everything counts, step by step. Much MUCH respect. Keep moving brotha

  • Ugh, I’m going through the same thing right now, Parry. I have to do a Chinese accent for the lead part in an indie feature I’m in. Unfortunately she’s a mail order bride from China, so I can’t avoid doing the accent.

    At first I wasn’t sure why I could do British, Southern, French accents easily, and I couldn’t do Chinese. Then I realized it’s because I find it degrading and I was preventing myself from hearing it in my head. I’ve rationalized that it’s just acting and now I can do it, but I don’t know if I’ll ever be 100% comfortable..

  • people like you make me proud to be an azn =]

  • it’s hard having to think about your impact on a community on a day-to-day basis. but, i congratulate you for your persistence and having the balls/guts to stick it to the man.

  • You’ve made it possible for Asian Americans to be acknowledged as Americans, foregoing the easy route which perpetuates the foreigner status in the few representative opportunities available. 

    Thanks for being so candid about your industry experiences on xanga.  I’m optimistic when I hear about people like Adam Green.  As one of so many people who read your xanga, I appreciate your generosity in sharing what you’ve learned and in making choices with care for others. 

  • Great post. What you did is very admirable and I have the utmost respect for how you carry yourself. Good luck with everything

  • Parry, I completely respect you being true to your beliefs.  I think it’s important for all actors–of any group, be it based on ethnicity, gender, sexuality, etc–to critically examine the characters they bring to life in stories.  It’s important to ask such questions as, “Does the role I play create more hurt in the world?”

    That said (and I do not know the full details of your situation so it very well may not apply to you), there are Asians who speak with accents.  Being Asian I grew up and worked with many Asians, from different parts of the world, who did not speak “Standard American English.”  And therefore it can be a legitimate choice by either the writer, director, or actor to use an “Asian accent.”

    I just finished a run of a play in which I faced a similar dilemma.  And like you, I chose not to audition with an accent.  I was cast, and during the rehearsal process the director, who is white, asked me to try a Asian accent.  In the end, I did use an accent for most of the play.  Not until the end of the play, does my character drop the accent and it is revealed that he was “playing a role” the entire time.  Understand that this choice–an Asian who can speak with or without an accent–was not at all specified in the script.  Fortunately, the director and playwright saw value in this device.  My point being that it is not inherently bad for an actor of Asian descent to speak with a “stereotypical” accent.  It can serve a narrative purpose and be of some good.

    In no way am I trying to be a smart aleck or to mock your efforts.  I had to respond to this post because of all comments from your readers that seem to be coming from a place of, “The Man is keeping us down.”  Not everything is as it seems…

  • Your gonna looooove the interview with James Hong in my new book. Rock on, man. Good job.

  • You make a great point, I think the ability to speak an Asian Accent from an Asian American is an art and skill. I don’t even know how to make an Asian Accent, it just comes out Middle Eastern. If anything these actors should be expected to have any other accent besides the usual asian….like…Jamaican….now that would be hilarious.

  • WELL DONE, Parry for standing up for something you believe in !  MAJOR PROPS !

  • You’re a brave man, and I admire you for it. :D

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *